Interesting Bars
  1. Home
  2. New York City
  3. Sunken Harbor Club

Sunken Harbor Club

372 Fulton Street, 2nd Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201
+1 (347) 689‑3677
info@sunkenharbor.club
26
$$$$
View Website
tiki
experience

Sunken Harbor Club is a cozy, maritime-themed cocktail bar perched above the historic Gage & Tollner on the second floor at 372 Fulton Street, Downtown Brooklyn. Blending tiki‑style escapism with adventurous storytelling, it’s designed to feel like the interior of a galleon mid‑voyage: wooden beams, rope rigging, antique fishing floats, and a glowing mermaid mural behind the bar set the scene. Born in 2014 as a pop-up at Fort Defiance and made permanent in 2017, the bar is helmed by Garret Richard, author of Tropical Standard, with drinks crafted by a team that values creative, story‑driven cocktails grounded in global flavors. The menu is neatly organized into sections—In the Shallows, The Twilight Zone, The Abyss, and On Dry Land—ranging from light, fizzy elixirs to strong rum punches and well-balanced classics. Expect cocktails priced in the ~$18–$22 range (standard around $20) along with occasional finger foods like shrimp toast, sliders, and oysters. Walk-ins only; capacity is limited to ~35 guests, so early arrival is smart—great for date nights, small groups, or anyone craving a sea‑faring escape without leaving the borough. Sunken Harbor Club also launched a sister location in Bermuda in 2022, continuing its tradition of rum‑forward, vessel‑inspired experiences.

Sunken Harbor Club - Image 1
View on Google Maps

Reviews

No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

More Bars in New York City

The Chapel - Image 1
$$$$
speakeasy
cocktails
live-music

The Chapel

The Chapel Bar is a moody speakeasy-style lounge inside a restored 19th-century chapel adjacent to Fotografiska, with jewel tones, velvet booths, creative cocktails & live events. A dramatic spot for late-night elegance.

Read more
Shinji’s - Image 1
$$$$
concept
cocktails
whiskey

Shinji’s

Shinji’s is an immersive, intimate 18‑seat cocktail bar in Flatiron offering theatrical, nostalgia‑inspired drinks with technical flair, rare Japanese whisky, and tableside hand‑rolls in an opulent, moody setting.

Read more
Sip & Guzzle - Image 1
$$$$
mixology
speakeasy

Sip & Guzzle

Discover dual‑level elegance at Sip & Guzzle: start upstairs for vibrant 1860s‑style saloon vibes, then descend into a tranquil Japanese‑inspired speakeasy—astounding cocktails and izakaya fare await.

Read more
Clemente Bar - Image 1
$$$$
artistic
cocktails

Clemente Bar

An art-filled, plant-forward cocktail haven perched above Eleven Madison Park—Clemente Bar blends evocative murals by Francesco Clemente with precision-crafted drinks and refined bar bites in an intimate, stylish lounge.

Read more
Sake Bar Decibel - Image 1
$$$$
cosy
aesthetic

Sake Bar Decibel

Dive into Decibel: NYC’s underground sake pioneer—punk riffs, neon signs, and 100+ sakes served beneath East 9th Street in a dim, intimate den where music, sake, and counterculture collide.

Read more
Employees Only - Image 1
$$$$
Speakeasy
Cocktails

Employees Only

Employees Only NYC is a legendary speakeasy hidden behind a psychic’s storefront in the West Village. Known for expertly crafted cocktails, late-night vibes, and top-notch hospitality, it’s a must-visit for cocktail lovers.

Read more
Katana Kitten - Image 1
$$$$
cosy
speakeasy

Katana Kitten

Tokyo-meets-West-Village charm in a bi-level izakaya bar: expert highballs, inventive cocktails & Japanese-American bites served warm by “Masa” himself. Cheeky, cozy, unforgettable.

Read more
The Campbell - Image 1
$$$$
historical
live-music
cocktails

The Campbell

A gilded‑age masterpiece hidden in plain sight—step into The Campbell, where soaring Florentine ceilings, plush mohair seats, a historic safe‑fireplace, and live piano jazz blend into timeless elegance.

Read more
Apotheke - Image 1
$$$$
mixology
speakeasy
cosy

Apotheke

Hidden behind a historic door in Chinatown, Apotheke is a theatrical apothecary‑themed speakeasy where white‑coat bartenders craft medicinal-style cocktails using house-made tinctures for an immersive, chemistry-inspired experience.

Read more

Interesting Bars

© 2025 Interesting Bars. All rights reserved.

Instagram

·

Built by Phil

Company

About

Blog

Product

Cities

Countries

Categories

Bars Near You

Legal

Terms

Privacy

Copyright & Image Policy