Interesting Bars
  1. Home
  2. New York City
  3. Sunken Harbor Club

Sunken Harbor Club

372 Fulton Street, 2nd Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201
+1 (347) 689‑3677
info@sunkenharbor.club
$$$$
View Website
tiki
experience

Sunken Harbor Club is a cozy, maritime-themed cocktail bar perched above the historic Gage & Tollner on the second floor at 372 Fulton Street, Downtown Brooklyn. Blending tiki‑style escapism with adventurous storytelling, it’s designed to feel like the interior of a galleon mid‑voyage: wooden beams, rope rigging, antique fishing floats, and a glowing mermaid mural behind the bar set the scene. Born in 2014 as a pop-up at Fort Defiance and made permanent in 2017, the bar is helmed by Garret Richard, author of Tropical Standard, with drinks crafted by a team that values creative, story‑driven cocktails grounded in global flavors. The menu is neatly organized into sections—In the Shallows, The Twilight Zone, The Abyss, and On Dry Land—ranging from light, fizzy elixirs to strong rum punches and well-balanced classics. Expect cocktails priced in the ~$18–$22 range (standard around $20) along with occasional finger foods like shrimp toast, sliders, and oysters. Walk-ins only; capacity is limited to ~35 guests, so early arrival is smart—great for date nights, small groups, or anyone craving a sea‑faring escape without leaving the borough. Sunken Harbor Club also launched a sister location in Bermuda in 2022, continuing its tradition of rum‑forward, vessel‑inspired experiences.

Sunken Harbor Club - Image 1
View on Google Maps

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!

More Bars in New York City

The Campbell - Image 1
$$$$
historical
live-music
cocktails

The Campbell

15 Vanderbilt Avenue, Grand Central Terminal, New York, NY 10017, USA

A gilded‑age masterpiece hidden in plain sight—step into The Campbell, where soaring Florentine ceilings, plush mohair seats, a historic safe‑fireplace, and live piano jazz blend into timeless elegance.

Lantern’s Keep - Image 1
$$$$
speakeasy
cocktails
sophisticated

Lantern’s Keep

49 West 44th Street, New York, NY 10036, USA

Lantern’s Keep: a timeless speakeasy tucked behind the lobby of the Iroquois Hotel—expect pre-Prohibition cocktails, plush velvet seats, soft lighting & a refuge from the Midtown buzz.

Thyme Bar - Image 1
$$$$
cocktails
aesthetic
speakeasy

Thyme Bar

20 West 23rd Street, Cellar, Flatiron District, New York, NY 10010, USA

Descend into Flatiron’s pre-war cellar & taste cocktails as art—botanical whispers, immersive presentations & a tasting escape beneath 23rd Street.

Martiny’s - Image 1
$$$$
artistic
sophisticated
historical

Martiny’s

121 E 17th Street, Gramercy Park, New York, NY 10003

A refined Japanese‑style cocktail lounge nestled in an 1800s carriage house in Gramercy—Martiny’s blends Tokyo hospitality and artistry with theatrical drinks, Kimura glassware, warm oshibori towels, and luxurious omakase‑style service.

Le Boudoir - Image 1
$$$$
speakeasy
aesthetic

Le Boudoir

135 Atlantic Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

A Marie Antoinette–inspired speakeasy hidden beneath Brooklyn Heights—a plush Rococo hideaway down a secret bookshelf, where decadent absinthe cocktails and burlesque nights meet 19th-century subway tunnel thrills.

Sake Bar Decibel - Image 1
$$$$
cosy
aesthetic

Sake Bar Decibel

240 East 9th Street, Manhattan, NY 10003, United States

Dive into Decibel: NYC’s underground sake pioneer—punk riffs, neon signs, and 100+ sakes served beneath East 9th Street in a dim, intimate den where music, sake, and counterculture collide.

Raines Law Room - Image 1
$$$$
secret
sophisticated

Raines Law Room

48 W 17th Street, New York, NY 10011, USA

Step through a secret buzzer into an elegant 1920s‑inspired parlor where plush sofas, dim lighting, and tailored cocktails await. Raines Law Room offers speakeasy charm, refined atmosphere, and intimate conversations—NYC’s covert cocktail hideaway.

Bemelmans Bar - Image 1
$$$$
piano-bar
sophisticated
historical

Bemelmans Bar

35 East 76th Street, The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel, Upper East Side, Manhattan, New York, NY 10021, USA

Step into artful elegance at Bemelmans Bar in the Carlyle Hotel—where Madeline’s creator’s murals gleam under gold-leaf ceilings, live piano sets the mood, and signature “very dirty” martinis define timeless Gotham sophistication.

The Sunken Lounge (TWA Hotel) - Image 1
$$$$
experience
aesthetic
historical

The Sunken Lounge (TWA Hotel)

One Idlewild Drive, JFK International Airport, Queens, NY 11430, USA

Step back into the Jet Age at The Sunken Lounge — mid-century glam, retro cocktails, poolside runway views & swizzle sticks that once flew at 30,000 ft.

Interesting Bars

© 2025 Interesting Bars. All rights reserved.

Instagram

·

Built by Phil

Company

About

Blog

Product

Cities

Countries

Categories

Legal

Terms

Privacy