Sunken Harbor Club is a cozy, maritime-themed cocktail bar perched above the historic Gage & Tollner on the second floor at 372 Fulton Street, Downtown Brooklyn. Blending tikiâstyle escapism with adventurous storytelling, itâs designed to feel like the interior of a galleon midâvoyage: wooden beams, rope rigging, antique fishing floats, and a glowing mermaid mural behind the bar set the scene. Born in 2014 as a pop-up at Fort Defiance and made permanent in 2017, the bar is helmed by Garret Richard, author of Tropical Standard, with drinks crafted by a team that values creative, storyâdriven cocktails grounded in global flavors. The menu is neatly organized into sectionsâIn the Shallows, The Twilight Zone, The Abyss, and On Dry Landâranging from light, fizzy elixirs to strong rum punches and well-balanced classics. Expect cocktails priced in the ~$18â$22 range (standard around $20) along with occasional finger foods like shrimp toast, sliders, and oysters. Walk-ins only; capacity is limited to ~35 guests, so early arrival is smartâgreat for date nights, small groups, or anyone craving a seaâfaring escape without leaving the borough. Sunken Harbor Club also launched a sister location in Bermuda in 2022, continuing its tradition of rumâforward, vesselâinspired experiences.
Reviews
No reviews yet. Be the first to rate this bar and share your thoughts!
